Netherlands appeals European ruling on Starbucks

Netherlands appeals European ruling on Starbucks

The Netherlands have appealed the European Commission's ruling. It does not agree with the decision that the agreement between Starbucks and the Dutch government actually consists of illegal state aid.

Designed to avoid taxes

The European Commission feels Starbucks has not paid enough taxes in the Netherlands, because it had an agreement in place to pay royalties to an affiliate company in the United Kingdom as a fee for the roasting formula to create "actual" Starbucks coffee. This is how it managed to lower its Dutch-based profit and therefore taxes, but in actuality, its British company is a simple mailbox company.

 

That is why the European Commission equated this with state aid, which is only allowed under very strict regulations in Europe. An additional payment of 20 million euro needs to follow, the first time the European Commission actually demanded a recovery.

 

Netherlands points to OECD

The Dutch Ministry of Finance does not agree with the European ruling and State Secretary Eric Wiebes says the deal with Starbucks is in line with the OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) guidelines.

 

Wiebes feels this ruling creates uncertainty and ambiguity about the way the rules need to be applied and that is also why the Dutch government has appealed the decision.

 

The appropriate taxation of multinationals has become an important theme nowadays, especially as many countries want increased tax income. That increases pressure to get a decent level of taxation, while many smaller business feel they have to pay a lot more compared to multinationals who have managed to walk the road of least taxation. Luxembourg has previously been condemned for a similar deal with Fiat.

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors


EuroCommerce: protectionism, Europe’s greatest challenge

15/09/2017

(Content provided by EuroCommerce) According to EuroCommerce Director-General Christian Verschueren, the sector faces many challenges due to a rising tide of protectionism worldwide and within Europe.

Last ten days for cheaper tickets Shoptalk Europe

14/09/2017

(advertorial) Shoptalk Europe (8-11 October in Copenhagen) is the new event for retail and ecommerce innovation. It covers transformational trends, technologies and business models reshaping how consumers discover and shop in an age of digital disruption.

"EU has to define eCommerce's boundaries better"

13/09/2017

Dutch European Parliament member Marietje Schaak feels the European Commission should create a better framework for digital trade in and with European member states. Otherwise, major internet companies will decide the standards themselves, she fears.

Europe wants legal framework for franchisees

13/09/2017

The European Parliament has accepted the “The functioning of franchising in the retail sector” study, which lists several solutions to strengthen a franchisee’s position.

Google appeals European fine after all

12/09/2017

Despite earlier indications that Google would just alter its Google Shopping approach to comply with European legislation, it has now decided to appeal the monster fine.

Experience the future of retail at Paris Retail Week

12/09/2017

(Advertorial) If you want to spot the latest retail trends, go to visit the Paris Retail Week, from 19 until 21 September. It is a trade show, network event and knowledge center with more than 200 freely accessible conferences, keynotes, info sessions and workshops.

Back to top