RetailDetail EU
Europe - EN
  • België - NL
  • Belgique - FR
  • Nederland - NL
  • Europe - EN
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Inloggen
  • Abonneren
  • News
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Home
    • Electronics
    • Beauty/Care
    • DIY/Garden
    • Leisure
    • General
  • RetailDetail Plus
  • Events
  • Hunts
  • Advertising & Partnerships
    • EVENT PARTNERSHIPS
    • PRINT ADVERTISING
    • ONLINE ADVERTISING
  • RetailHub
RetailDetail EU
Europe - EN
  • België - NL
  • Belgique - FR
  • Nederland - NL
  • Europe - EN
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Sign in user
  • News
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Home
    • Electronics
    • Beauty/Care
    • DIY/Garden
    • Leisure
    • General
  • RetailDetail Plus
  • Events
  • Hunts
  • Advertising & Partnerships
    • EVENT PARTNERSHIPS
    • PRINT ADVERTISING
    • ONLINE ADVERTISING
  • RetailHub
  • Inloggen
  • Abonneren
thumb
Written by Jorg Snoeck
In this article
Share article
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • email

Dutch agricultural economist: 'No, supermarkets don't get rich off the backs of farmers'

icon
General12 January, 2021

Farmers blame the big chains for getting too little for their produce, but the supermarkets refute this. A Dutch agricultural economist nuances the discussion. “Nobody in the chain earns excessively,” states Willy Baltussen of Wageningen University.

 

No Covid-bonus for farmers

It is no coincidence that this topic now surfaces in the Netherlands. After a long period of debate, consultations between farmers and supermarket groups are taking place this week. The farmers argue that supermarket chains made good profits in 2020 thanks to hoarders, but those profits did not trickle down to the producers.

 

Of course, this is not a new discussion. Confrontations between angry farmers and final sellers of the products are a regular occurrence. In Germany, recently, a heated conflict took place between pig farmers and Lidl. After weeks of protest – including tractor blockades – the latter caved and raised its purchase prices for several pork products.

 

“It is complicated”

In the Netherlands, tempers are getting frayed. Since October 2019, farmers have been taking regular action to address a range of frustrations. Initially, the main focus was on the government’s measures in connection with new nitrogen legislation. But gradually, the issue of the purchase prices of supermarket chains also came up. Further negotiations will take place on Thursday at the Central Food Trade Office, the Dutch supermarket umbrella organisation.

 

However, the chances of farmers getting their money’s worth are small. The supermarkets resist the idea that they got rich from the coronavirus crisis. They also argue they have limited impact on what farmers get for their products as they are at the other end of the chain. “The solution is more complicated,” CEO of Jumbo Frits van Eerd said earlier. Baltussen agrees with that statement.

 

Profit is reasonably distributed

“Every party involved in the chain incurs costs and makes profits on certain products, but it seems that those profits are reasonably distributed,” Baltussen told Dutch newspaper De Gelderlander. “There is no party earning excessively from it. Not even the supermarkets.” Baltussen points mainly to the gap between supply and demand. “We have been in this situation for quite some time. Supermarkets can sit back and buy products. They will get the necessary products anyway and can wait for the lowest price.”

 

Farmers Defence Force, an advocacy organisation that saw the light of day in 2019 during the protest’s build-up, suggested introducing a certification mark for supermarket chains that explicitly buy from Dutch farmers, but it finds little favour. The CBL, the Dutch association for supermarkets, notices that a big chunk of Dutch agricultural production gets exported anyway. And, Baltussen calls the ‘Farmer Friendly’ label lopsided. “The farmers say: ‘This was produced in the Netherlands’. That’s it, nothing more. And supermarkets have to pay for that?”

 

The chances of an agreement being reached on Thursday are small. The structural issues remain: oversupply and a complex supply chain in which each party tries to make a profit. And perhaps above all: a Dutch consumer who attaches great importance to price when shopping at the supermarket.

Stay up-to-date

Receive our free newsletters and do not miss out on the latest retail news.

Subscribe
logo

Farmers blame the big chains for getting too little for their produce, but the supermarkets refute this. A Dutch agricultural economist nuances the discussion. “Nobody in the chain earns excessively,” states Willy Baltussen of Wageningen University.   No Covid-bonus for farmers It is no coincidence that this topic now surfaces in the Netherlands. After a long period of debate, consultations between farmers and supermarket groups are taking place this week. The farmers argue that supermarket chains made good profits in 2020 thanks to hoarders, but those profits did not trickle down to the producers.   Of course, this is not...

More on General
See more
  • icon
    General1 December, 2023
    TEDi announces Belgian expansion plans

    TEDi‘s Belgian expansion plans have so far only resulted in only one store, but that is about to change. Early next year, the chain will move further west.

  • icon
    General30 November, 2023
    Galeria looks for new owner after Signa collapse

    German department store chain Galeria is looking for a new owner now that Austrian parent company Signa Holding has collapsed. The chain, which also owns Belgian Inno, hopes to come away from its current owner’s financial predicaments unscathed.

  • icon
    General29 November, 2023
    Retail holding Signa starts insolvency proceedings

    Signa Holding, the holding that owns department store chains like Galeria, has filed for insolvency. The group hopes to be able to restructure under protection of the courts.

Most read
  • icon
    Home9 November, 2023
    How IKEA lowers prices and still maintains margins
  • icon
    Beauty/Care14 November, 2023
    German investor buys The Body Shop
  • icon
    Electronics16 November, 2023
    Bombshell in European electronics market: is JD.com taking over Media Markt?
  • icon
    Food15 November, 2023
    Investigation into abuse of power by Coca-Cola in Germany
Follow RetailDetail
  • socialFacebook
  • socialTwitter
  • socialInstagram
  • sociallinkedIn
footer-logo
RetailDetail, the leading b2b-retailcommunity in the Benelux, keeps retail professionals up-to-date by means of online & offline publications, retail events, inspiring retail hunts and the unique co-creation platform retailhub, where retailers and their suppliers can experience the future of shopping.
RetailDetail Mailing Address:
Kolveniersstraat 7, bus 26 
2000 Antwerp
Visiting address:
Stadsfeestzaal – Meir 78 
2000 Antwerp
How to reach us:
Directions
© 2023 RetailDetail
general conditions | privacy policy
+32 3 500 89 59 info@retaildetail.be
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Accept All
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT