American judge torpedoes digital second-hand stores

American judge torpedoes digital second-hand stores

Can you resell a song you downloaded legally and have paid for? According to an American judge, you can't: the verdict calls the entire system of digital second-hand stores into question. The verdict's consequences for Europe areuncertain at the moment.

Product or license?

It all comes down to a matter of principle: is a downloaded song just a digital version of something already released on cd? In other words: can you re-sell it like you would an old cd? Or do you only buy a license, which gives you the right to listen to the music - but not to resell it.

 

An American judge has decided that buying digital content is the same as getting a license, meaning it can not be sold again. The judged reached his verdict in a case against ReDiGi, an online platform focussed on the sale of second-hand downloads.

 

According to the company, the products were handed from one person to the next, without making a copy, but the judge saw it different. The ruling torpedoes the plans of several companies that wanted to start a similar business.

 

The consequences of the ruling in Europe are uncertain at the time. Analysts expect that a similar case has to be held here to come to a definitive conclusion.

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors


Luxury manufacturers can block retailers from selling on Amazon

07/12/2017

Luxury product manufactures can block retailers from selling their merchandise on online marketplaces like Amazon. The European Court of Justice has ruled on the matter after cosmetics manufacturer Coty filed a complaint.

Surge in mobile sales during Thanksgiving weekend

29/11/2017

During Thanksgiving weekend in the United States, which contains Black Friday and Cyber Monday, there was a big surge in mobile sales. Those two days saw a total sales figure of almost twelve billion dollar (just shy of ten billion euro).

Alibaba reveals its high-tech store of the future

24/11/2017

Amazon Go’s automated supermarkets have not yet arrived, but Alibaba already has its answers ready. The Chinese online retailer has showcased Tmall Supermart, filled with technology: from virtual fitting rooms to facial recognition.

Rakuten bridges gap to Japanese online consumer

30/10/2017

In Alibaba and Amazon’s shadow, Japanese Rakuten Ichiba is quickly developing. Several Western chains are using the platform to sell their products to Japanese online consumers.

Whole Foods contributes to Amazon's enormous turnover increase

27/10/2017

American Amazon’s third quarter turnover grew a lot once more, partially thanks to Whole Foods. This was the first time the chain’s turnover was added to Amazon’s overall turnover.

More than half of American families subscribed at Amazon

21/10/2017

An astonishing ninety million Americans have joined Amazon’s subscription program, Amazon Prime. Considering there are 126 million families in the United States, it is clear that Amazon has a tight grip on its home territory. What can Europe learn from this?

Back to top