American Supreme Court to tackle Abercrombie's hijab | RetailDetail

American Supreme Court to tackle Abercrombie's hijab

American Supreme Court to tackle Abercrombie's hijab

The American Supreme Court is currently tackling the case of a young Muslim woman who was not hired by Abercrombie & Fitch because of her headscarf. It looks like the nine judges will rule in favour of the plaintiff.

Clothing policy or discrimination

Back in 2008, Samanta Elauf (17 at the time) applied for a job as a sales model at Abercrombie & Fitch's children's department. The assistant manager gave her good grades and even recommended her to the district manager, mentioning she did wear a black headscarf, possibly because of religious beliefs. The district manager subsequently decided to change her scores and she did not get the job.

 

A lower court already decided the plaintiff was right, but Abercrombie & Fitch won on appeal: the applicant should have asked for an exception on the clothing rules, based on her religious beliefs. Abercrombie & Fitch feels headscarves do not fit the company's clothing policy, which prohibits black clothing and headgear. Elauf replied she was not informed about the company's clothing policy.

 

How much room for religion?

The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission intervened and brought the case to the Supreme Court, where its 9 judges now have to decide whether employers have to give their employees room for their religious beliefs.

 

Abercrombie stated it cannot know whether applicants do certain things because of their religious beliefs if they do not come forward with that information spontaneously, claiming that "Otherwise, we will have to train our people to recognize stereotypes", but the judges have seemingly moved in favour of the plaintiff.

 

The company has already adjusted its clothing policy: it has allowed headscarves, but black is still prohibited. 

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors


Ahold Delhaize launches digital lab in the United States

22/05/2018

Ahold Delhaize’s American division will found a new company focused on digital innovation: Peapod Digital Labs will become a lab for new digital, eCommerce and personalization strategies. 

Carrefour forced to shut down hundreds of Dia stores

22/05/2018

Carrefour has not found a buyer for hundreds of its former Dia stores in France yet. That may force nearly 230 stores to shut down.

Carrefour and Tencent launch high-tech store in Shanghai

22/05/2018

The recently launched ‘Le Marché’ store formula, a first collaboration between Carrefour and Tencent, allows customers to pay with face recognition at unmanned checkouts.

Hoegaarden moves part of production to Vietnam and China

18/05/2018

Hoegaarden experiences strong growth in Asia, but is losing ground in Europe. That is why AB InBev will move part of the production to China and Vietnam: the brewery in Hoegaarden will lower cut its production days by 2 a week.

Holland & Barrett wants vegan stores

17/05/2018

British health chain Holland & Barrett (previously known in the Benelux as Essenza) plans to open completely vegan stores, a trend the chain needs to follow according to CEO Peter Aldis.

Nestlé on a diet: cuts back sugar, fat and salt levels

17/05/2018

Nestlé wants to lower its sugar, salt and fat levels to play into the global demand for healthier food.