Retailers the wrong target for action on the supply chain | RetailDetail

Retailers the wrong target for action on the supply chain

Retailers the wrong target for action on the supply chain

(content provided by EuroCommerce) EuroCommerce Director-General Christian Verschueren has expressed his concern towards Agriculture Commissioner Phil Hogan that some of the statements in his speech on 5 October in Dublin could polarise the debate.

"Damaging picture"

“The speech has been portrayed by some of the European press as the Commission “declaring war on retailers”, which, as I am sure you will agree, paints quite a damaging picture of a relationship between the Commission and a sector that is key to providing a reliable supply of food to consumers at reasonable prices. Isn’t this what the CAP chapter of the Treaty, and the Commission as its guardian, also aim to ensure? We worry that by demonising retailers, the issue is again becoming polarised, when the supply chain needs reasoned debate and dialogue, based on factual evidence”, Verschueren writes. 


He also questions whether the announcement in the Commissioner’s speech of the Commission now working towards legislation on so-called unfair trading practices is not premature: “This surprised us considerably, as the Commission’s consultation leading to the substantive Impact Assessment runs until 17 November.  It is surely rather premature, and not in line with the Commission’s Better Regulation framework, to be announcing now that the Commission has already made up its mind what form any such action should take.”


The letter asks the Commission to provide concrete evidence that EU legislation will be able to achieve its stated aim of improving farmers’ situation in the supply chain: “The Inception Impact Assessment did not supply any new evidence to support abandonment of the Commission’s conclusion just a year ago that EU-level legislation offered no added value. It only presented a couple of perception studies dating back a number of years, as evidence of a problem between farmers and retailers. And it did not address the basic question which the Commission needs to answer in advocating EU legislation:  if retailers do not deal significantly with farmers, and if most of the practices identified by the Agri-Markets Task Force apply principally or exclusively to retailers’ dealing with large multinational brands, what can EU legislation covering these practices do to help the position of farmers?”


Verschueren concluded by stressing the importance in all of this debate of the consumer: “We agree with the Commission on many points in looking to improve the position of farmers – more transparency, better cooperation among farmers… But if such legislation squeezes retailers further in dealing with their large suppliers, it is the consumer - whom the Inception Impact Assessment incidentally failed to mention once – who will end up footing the bill.”

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors

Gerelateerde items

Régis Degelcke new EuroCommerce president


Régis Degelcke is the new president of EuroCommerce. The chairman of Auchan will start his three-year mandate in July.

Tom&Co eyes 100 French stores


Belgian pet shop chain Tom&Co continues its expansion in France with the opening of its 25th French store in Nantes. With a new concept, the chain hopes to be able to quickly expand to 100 stores in France.

France wants e-commerce tax


If the French government get their way, the Hexagon will soon introduce a tax on e-commerce. Products would become 1 to 2 % more expensive, depending on the distance of the last delivery.

Toy store chain La Grande Récré pulls plug on Belgium


French toy store chain La Grande Récré has decided to focus on the French market and to close its Belgian branch, due to continuing financial difficulties. 16 stores will close, causing a job loss of 95.

Join us for Europe’s largest retail and e-retail event!


(advertorial) The fourth edition of Paris Retail Week will take place September 10 – 12, 2018 in Pavilion 1 at Paris Expo Porte de Versailles. For three days, Paris will be the capital of experiential and connected commerce, bringing together 800 participating companies and 40,000 retail and e-commerce professionals.

Karstadt aims to reinvent department stores in Berlin


German department store chain Karstadt is to open two stores in Berlin, that aim to reinvent themselves as a "networked marketplace". It will be the first new Karstadt department stores in the German capital for thirty years.