European Court says retail is a service, and planning restrictions must be proportional | RetailDetail

European Court says retail is a service, and planning restrictions must be proportional

European Court says retail is a service, and planning restrictions must be proportional
© Marc Venema /

(Content provided by EuroCommerce) In a long-awaited ruling in the Visser case last week, the Court of Justice confirmed that distributive trade (retail & wholesale) is to be considered a service activity within the meaning of the Directive.


Directive applies to all cases

It also said that the Directive applies to all cases, even when no cross-border element is present. In this case, the Court concluded that the Dutch municipality of Appingedam included a territorial restriction requirement (Services Directive, Art. 15(2) a) in its zoning plan. It rules that such restrictions needed to be non-discriminatory, justified by an overriding reason of public interest, and proportionate (Art. 15(3)). In this particular case, the Appingendam municipality laid down rules “in a zoning plan, pursuant to which certain geographical zones situated outside the city centre are exclusively designated for retail trade in bulky goods.”


Based on this, a retailer was prohibited from opening a clothing and shoe store outside the city centre. Appingedam argued that the ‘requirement’ was justified to maintain the viability of the city centre and to avoid there being vacant premises in the city, in the interest of good town and country planning. The Court of Justice recognised this could constitute a valid overriding reason of public interest, but left it to the High Supreme Court of the Netherlands to make a proportionality assessment of such restrictive requirements.

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors

Gerelateerde items

Walmart and Microsoft team up to beat Amazon


Two major American companies join forces to try to beat the omnipresent threat of Amazon: Walmart (Amazon's biggest competitor in retail) and Microsoft (Amazon's main rival in cloud services) have signed a strategic partnership for the next five years.

Sales of PCs grows for the first time in six years


For the first time in six years computer sales showed growth again: in the second quarter of 2018 they increased by 1.4%. According to research firms Gartner and IDC, the sales increase is mainly due to growth in business markets.

Retailhub Inspiration Tour: the customer journey becomes very different


Thanks to Retailhub by RetailDetail, Antwerp has one more unique retail hot spot. Professionals can experience the future of retail in the Benelux' only retail inspiration platform, with 1250 sqm of innovative technology and huge trends.

Breakthrough in Karstadt-Kaufhof merger


Canadian Hudson’s Bay and Austrian Sigma Holding have not reached a preliminary agreement about the merger of their respective department store chains Kaufhof and Karstadt: the Canadian company says it has only signed a letter of intent.

Alibaba CEO and Belgian PM discuss investment in Liège


Alibaba founder Jack Ma has discussed a possible investment in Liège, Belgium with the country's prime minister Charles Michel. Afterwards no decisive statements were made by either party.

Toys "R" Us closes American stores amidst reboot hopes


Final curtains for Toys "R" Us in the United States: all the stores have closed and 30,000 employees are laid off. Against all odds, some however still hope for a second life for the troubled chain.