Carrefour has to pay Intermarché 800,000 euro fine

Carrefour has to pay Intermarché 800,000 euro fine

A Parisian court has fined Carrefour 800,000 euro, after ruling that competitor Intermarché's complaint because of "derogatory and deceptive comparing advertising" had its merits, even though Carrefour mainly targeted E.Leclerc with the ads.

TV price war

Early 2013, Carrefour France used TV ads to compare prices with its competitors, as a reaction to the QuiEstLeMoinsCher.com website (launched by E.Leclerc). Both companies are constantly fighting to be the French market leader and E.Leclerc's website showed that Carrefour was consistently more expensive than E.Leclerc.

 

Carrefour's counter, spearheaded by its (at the time its newly-installed) CEO Georges Plassat, was designed to put the record straight... which did not please another competitor, Intermarché. According to Carrefour's price comparison, Intermarché was 9.8 to 12.4 % more expensive. The latter demanded to know how the numbers were calculated, and in the end, it dragged Carrefour to court because of "derogatory and deceptive advertising".

 

"Loose interpretation of comparative ad legislation"

The Parisian Commercial Court has now fined Carrefour 800,000 euro, as the distributor failed to uphold the consumer legislation. More specifically, the court felt Carrefour "interpreted the comparative ad legislation too loosely".

 

Other judges had deemed earlier price comparisons, even when they were limited to a small number of products and stores, to be acceptable, but this judge apparently felt Carrefour crossed a line here. The company still has the option to appeal the decision.

Questions or comments? Please feel free to contact the editors


EuroCommerce: protectionism, Europe’s greatest challenge

15/09/2017

(Content provided by EuroCommerce) According to EuroCommerce Director-General Christian Verschueren, the sector faces many challenges due to a rising tide of protectionism worldwide and within Europe.

Last ten days for cheaper tickets Shoptalk Europe

14/09/2017

(advertorial) Shoptalk Europe (8-11 October in Copenhagen) is the new event for retail and ecommerce innovation. It covers transformational trends, technologies and business models reshaping how consumers discover and shop in an age of digital disruption.

"EU has to define eCommerce's boundaries better"

13/09/2017

Dutch European Parliament member Marietje Schaak feels the European Commission should create a better framework for digital trade in and with European member states. Otherwise, major internet companies will decide the standards themselves, she fears.

Europe wants legal framework for franchisees

13/09/2017

The European Parliament has accepted the “The functioning of franchising in the retail sector” study, which lists several solutions to strengthen a franchisee’s position.

Google appeals European fine after all

12/09/2017

Despite earlier indications that Google would just alter its Google Shopping approach to comply with European legislation, it has now decided to appeal the monster fine.

Experience the future of retail at Paris Retail Week

12/09/2017

(Advertorial) If you want to spot the latest retail trends, go to visit the Paris Retail Week, from 19 until 21 September. It is a trade show, network event and knowledge center with more than 200 freely accessible conferences, keynotes, info sessions and workshops.

Back to top